• The People v. Donald Trump

    March 27, 2023

    Tags: , , , ,
    Posted in: Democracy, Trump

    Here are six things to think about ahead of any indictment and arrest of Donald Trump:

    1 – What is Trump going to be indicted for? Trump may soon be indicted on a campaign finance law violation. This means Manhattan district attorney Alvin Bragg (Federal prosecutors seem to have long signed out of the cheesy political revenge fantasy business) has convinced a grand jury there is enough evidence to charge Trump with the crime. Since this was a grand jury, Bragg faced no opposition in laying out his case, as the not-quite-a-defendant is not represented. So no cross examination, no motions to suppress evidence, no hammering away at Michael Cohen as perhaps the least credible witness of all time. The old joke is a clever DA can indict a ham sandwich, and if Trump is indicted that motto holds true here.

    2- But I thought this was all about Trump having an affair with some porn star? Stormy Daniels allegedly had sex with Trump in 2006, which he denies, and  which she and Michael Cohen once also denied. She then took money in 2016 to sign a nondisclosure agreement (NDA) to keep silent. Sensing an opportunity when the businessman later ran for president, she willfully violated the NDA to revive her career and profit off selling her story to the National Enquirer. Meanwhile, when faced with jail time for all sorts of dirty deeds, the businessman’s now disbarred former lawyer, a felon himself, violated attorney-client privilege to claim on his word the NDA payoffs were actually complex technical violations of campaign finance law. If this all sounds complicated, it’s because it is. No wonder even the Washington Post labels this a “zombie case.”

    3 – So the problem is the hush money paid in 2016? Not really but sort of. Paying money as part of an NDA is not illegal; lawyers regularly obtain discreet resolutions of issues threatening the interests of their clients. Without admitting guilt, money is paid from Party A to Party B in return for dropping all future claims, agreeing to never mention something again, handing over documents or photos, whatever you’d like. It happens all the time, and in fact is the dirty little secret which keeps sexual harassment alive and well. Wealthy men pay women to remain silent under NDAs. It does not change the legality of all this even if the media calls those payments hush money or payoffs. The what in this case (money for silence) is clear. It is the why that matters most. The why also affects any potential sentence; Trump lying would be a misdemeanor if it is proved that all he did was falsify his business records. But it could be a felony if prosecutors can prove that the falsification was tied to another crime and that’s where campaign finance laws come in.

    4 – The case, if it ever goes to trial, will hinge on intent, what Trump intended the money to do for him, according to Cohen. One has to intend to violate campaign finance laws. Any illegality comes from the supposition by Michael Cohen that he can speak to Trump’s intent, that the NDA was not, say, merely to spare Trump’s marriage some new embarrassment, but “for the principal purpose of influencing an election.” If the purpose was hiding Stormy from voters instead of hiding Stormy from Trump’s wife, then the money could be seen as a campaign contribution and whole new set of laws kick in. But “it should be clear,” says the New York Law Journal, “Cohen’s plea, obtained under pressure and with the ultimate aim of developing a case against the president, cannot in and of itself establish whether Trump had the requisite mental state.” If DA Bragg has other key witnesses beyond Stormy and Cohen he has not signaled as such.
    It’ll be up to a jury to decide if Cohen’s testimony proves Trump knew the payments made to Stormy were illegal. Prosecutors would have to prove that willingness by Trump alongside proving his principal goal was to influence the election. If this ever reaches court, Trump will simply deny everything and it would be a rare jury that says weighing one man’s word against another, especially these knuckleheads, eliminates all reasonable doubt. Felons testifying out of self interest make poor witnesses. Michael Cohen pleaded guilty to eight criminal offenses, including lying to Congress, tax fraud, and campaign finance violations. Cohen will face questions of personal bias, given his own multiple lawsuits against Trump. He will face questions about whether he received a benefit from prosecutors, early release from prison, for cooperating.
    5 – Seems like an awful lot rests on what the jury “believes” versus what can be proven. Trump need only introduce doubt to prevail here. But that’s not where the jury question will first come up. Trump’s lawyers are already hinting they will demand a change of venue, that by this time everyone in New York either loves or hates Trump (mostly hates, going back to the 1980s) and it will be impossible to seat an impartial jury in Manhattan. Moving the whole show to say Pittsburgh or Seattle will only increase the circus-like atmosphere and will add to Trump’s public-facing argument that this is all unfair.
    6 – Trump denies the affair. So how do we know he paid Stormy to keep quiet about the sex? DA Bragg will need to do some heavy lifting to connect Trump directly to the NDA payment. The check for $35,000 from Trump to Cohen, which was supposedly part of $135k paid to Stormy Daniels, Michael Cohen displayed at his 2019 Congressional hearing and ten others alleged to exist do not show what the payments were for. The checks do not have Stormy’s name on them. Cohen simply claimed they were part of his reimbursement for “illegal hush money I paid on his behalf.” The check(s) are not receipts; they could have been for anything. That Cohen denied everything until 2018 when he changed to confessing everything will feature in any Trump trial.
    Under direct questioning before Congress, Cohen claimed there was no corroborating evidence. He said he sent fake invoices to Trump only for “legal retainer fees,” so don’t bother with the invoices as evidence because Cohen now says he lied on them. The checks total over $400k, because supposedly Trump rolled Cohen’s fee and bonus into the amount, so we just have to take his word for it $135k of that money was for Stormy. Cohen said some of the checks were signed by Don, Jr. and the felony-convicted tax cheat former Trump Organization CFO Alan Weisselberg. That means the checks would be used to implicate personally a person who did not sign them.
    If this case comes to trial, Trump’s side will drag its feet at every step, hoping to push the verdict past the 2024 election. There is nothing to stop Trump from running for president if he is under indictment, or even if somehow found guilty and serving time. His affair with Stormy has been part of the public conversation around Trump for years and is well-digested by voters. There are elements here which would cause a reasonable man to call this overcriminalization, an act of political revenge, an attempt to derail the Trump campaign by the DA in New York. Would Trump garner more sympathy votes than those he might lose running as the first-ever indicted presidential candidate? Will voters object to a district attorney in New York trying to play kingmaker in the 2024 election, taking the vote out of the voter’s hands? Isn’t arresting political opponents a Third World thing? Playing with fire around Trump is never a good idea.

    Related Articles:

    Copyright © 2020. All rights reserved. The views expressed here are solely those of the author(s) in their private capacity.

  • Recent Comments

    • Rich Bauer said...


      Donnie Trump is a double agent. He is more valuable to the Dems White House 2024 chances by remaining free as a bird…brain. Fox figured it out finally. It broadcasts its warning. But his cult isn’t listening.

      03/27/23 9:54 PM | Comment Link

    • Rich Bauer said...


      This is the “people” Donnie has to fear:

      Weisselberg is about flip on the Don, just as Michael Cohen did before he flipped on Trump. Cassidy Hutchinson had a Trump-funded lawyer before she fired him and got another lawyer so she could tell the Jan. 6 investigatory committee the truth about what she learned working for former chief of staff Mark Meadows. Each time a Trump-funded lawyer was fired, it has been an indication that those previous allies were about to turn.

      Weisselberg is serving a five-month sentence in Rikers Island Prison, known for being one of the most violent prisons in America. It should be noted that if someone was trying to get Weisselberg to flip, now would be the time. Last month, the New York Times reported that the Manhattan prosecutor’s office was pondering whether to file new charges against Weisselberg for fraud.

      Of course Donnie will say he hardly knows the guy.

      03/29/23 10:11 PM | Comment Link

    • John Poole said...


      Bauer- do you really have sympathy for a creep like Weisellberg or any of Trump’s “trusted” employees? They were amply paid for their sleazy protection services. If Trump has indeed cheated many rough tradesmen why hasn’t one of them put out a contract on the Don? A suitable hit location? Easy. 5th Ave in New York City. Trump never bragged he couldn’t be shot dead in such a public spot.

      03/30/23 9:24 AM | Comment Link

    • Rich Bauer said...


      As WMW/TAC faithfully tracks the Fox Populies, it cant be long before Peter writes an inciteful article about the BIDEN New Jersey Wind Turbine farms causing whales to kill themselves. The only whale that may be beached in New Jersey is of course Donnie Trump.

      03/30/23 2:10 PM | Comment Link

    • Rich Bauer said...


      Peter pans the New York justice system

      Peter: Will voters object to a district attorney in New York trying to play kingmaker in the 2024 election, taking the vote out of the voter’s hands? Isn’t arresting political opponents a Third World thing?

      So the US is now a Banana Republic? Actually the US became a Banana Republic when the obese dickhead tyrant wannabe tried to take the vote away from the voters, and sent his LOST BOYS, Proud Boys and Oafkeepers, to attack the Capitol.

      The Trump Cult will never grow up, seeking to live in Never(black people) Land. So the rest of US will have to continue living in a mixed society…you know, REALITY.

      04/2/23 12:35 PM | Comment Link

    Leave A Comment

    Mail (will not be published) (required)