• Trump Again Proposes End of Birthright Citizenship

    August 27, 2024

    Tags: , , ,
    Posted in: Democracy

    Candidate Donald Trump renewed his pledge to end a long-standing constitutional right, saying he would sign an executive order on day one ensuring children born to parents who do not have legal status will not be considered U.S. citizens, as they are now. “The United States is among the only countries in the world that says even if neither parent is a citizen or even lawfully in the country, their future children are automatic citizens the moment the parents trespass onto our soil,” Trump said. What are Trump’s chances of success with such an executive order?

    Since the end of the Civil War, any child born in the U.S. (excluding the children of foreign diplomats, who are not born “subject to the jurisdiction of the United States”) is a citizen, the doctrine of jus soli. This right is written into the 14th Amendment to the Constitution (1868), which says “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States.” The language was included in the constitutional amendment enacted after the Civil War to ensure former slaves and their children were recognized as citizens.

    The rule is simple: born in the U.S. equals for almost everyone citizenship. It does not matter if one or both parents is an illegal alien or in some other status, such as a tourist (see “birth tourism, below.) Changing the rule, as Trump again proposes (Trump pledged to end birthright citizenship when first running for president in 2015 and he raised it again in 2018 as chief executive. But he never issued an executive order), has apart from a nearly insurmountable challenge of needing to amend the Constitution if the Executive Order survives lower courts, also bothers the question of birthright citizenship having been subjected to legal tests dating back to the turn of last century. It is possible the Supreme Court would not even hear the new case as the law is so clear.

    Chief among these tests was Wong Kim Ark v. United States (1898). Wong concerned a Chinese man born in the United States to two non-citizen parents. Under the 14th Amendment, he was granted American citizenship at birth. He left the U.S. and upon return was denied entry based on the Chinese Exclusion Act, which prohibited Chinese citizens from entering. Wong fought the case to the Supreme Court, which ruled in his favor, declaring him and all subsequent children born in the U.S. (except diplomats) citizens regardless of their parents’ status. The later case of Plyler v. Doe (1982) eliminated any doubt over whether Wong applies to all aliens, even illegal aliens.

    The Supreme Court’s majority concluded the phrase from the 14th Amendment “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” referred to being required to obey U.S. law; on this basis, they interpreted the language of the 14th Amendment in a way that granted U.S. citizenship to children born to foreigners. The dissenters argued being subject to the jurisdiction of the United States meant not also being subject to any foreign power, i.e., not being claimed as a citizen by another country via jus sanguinis (inheriting citizenship from a parent. That reading in the minority’s view would exclude “the children of foreigners, happening to be born to them while passing through the country.” The judgment was controversial from the start; an editorial published in the San Francisco Chronicle on March 30, 1898, expressed concern Wong “may have a wider effect upon the question of citizenship than the public supposes.” Specifically, that it might lead to citizenship and voting rights not only for Chinese but also Japanese and American Indians. The editorial suggested that “it may become necessary… to amend the Federal Constitution and definitely limit citizenship to whites and blacks.”

    All of this could affect birth tourism. In his last administration, Trump issued an executive order outlawing B1/B2 tourist visas for birth tourism, where an alien comes to the U.S. specifically to give birth here and “create” an American  citizen, an “anchor baby,” who will file for legal status for his parents at age 21. Prior to Trump’s E.O., traveling to the U.S. to give birth was fundamentally legal, although there are scattered cases of domestic authorities arresting operators of birth tourism agencies. Women abroad were often honest about their intentions when applying for visas and even show contracts with doctors and hospitals to prove they would not become public charges.

    As it stands, visitors will be denied temporary visas if it’s found the “primary purpose” of their travel is to obtain citizenship for a child by giving birth in the United States. The rule does not apply to the 39 countries in the Visa Waiver Program, and State in implementing the E.O. forbids its visa officers from even asking in most cases if an applicant is pregnant, making the order hard to enforce. “This is the first recognition that it’s not OK to use a visitor visa for the purposes of ‘birth tourism,’ so it has a symbolic strength in that respect, at the same time it’s not a very effective way at going after the ‘birth tourism’ industry,” said an analyst at the Migration Policy Institute. While the federal government does not specifically track birth tourism, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention annually publishes the number of known births in the U.S. to foreign women who reside overseas — around 10,000 such births every year for the past few years.

    Though Project 2025 does not mention birthright citizenship, if Trump were to follow through on his plan to issue an executive order on day one, here’s how it might unfold. The Trump campaign said it would order the Social Security Administration to refuse to issue Social Security numbers to newborn children without proof of the parents’ immigration status. Trump would issue the same order to the State Department regarding passports. This would not require any action from Congress and because it would not grant/take away citizenship per se, would not directly rub against the 14th Amendment.

    Currently, a U.S. birth certificate is all that is needed to obtain a Social Security number and passport in most cases. The State Department currently considers U.S.-born children of illegal aliens to be subject to U.S. jurisdiction, and thus to have citizenship at birth. The State Department’s Foreign Affairs Manual takes the position Wong settled this issue. This means the Trump E.O. would likely be challenged immediately in lower courts and because it does not directly address the 14th Amendment, would be ripe for the Supreme Court to use to revisit Wong indirectly if they wished to. The Court could also side with long precedent and refuse to even hear the case. The latter is the most likely outcome, and Trump’s third try at changing birthright citizenship would end just like his two earlier two.

    Related Articles:




    Copyright © 2024. All rights reserved. The views expressed here are solely those of the author(s) in their private capacity.

  • Recent Comments

    • Rich Bauer said...

      1

      While we are at it, let US remove the citizenship of idiots who attacked the Capitol. Deport them to Russia. Yes, that would include Donnie Dementia. Adios, mother fuckers!

      08/28/24 7:53 AM | Comment Link

    • John Poole said...

      2

      The founding father’s “sin of slavery” continues to be visited upon all their sons -and daughters. Granting citizenship to people forcefully brought to this country as slaves once “emancipated” was a misguided attempt at redemption and the blowback now is being visited upon us all.
      Why isn’t George Santos in prison for deceptively selling his “husbandhood” to a Brazilian babe? Miraculously, his ex wife can’t be reached for comment. She has a child. Is George paying child support? Is his name listed as the father on her birth certificate? Unlikely. Deport her and the child but give them permanent travel visas from Brazil for humane reasons so the child can visit his or her dad in prison here for his criminal deception.

      08/28/24 10:24 AM | Comment Link

    • Rich Bauer said...

      3

      Two Wongs don’t make a Right.. Trump University making a comeback? Enroll here and get a green card and US citizenship. Despite Trump blocking high-skilled immigrants, he says he favors giving green cards to all foreign graduates of U.S. universities.

      During four years as president, Trump never proposed increasing the admission of college-educated immigrants or awarding automatic green cards to all international students graduating from U.S. universities. His administration enacted numerous restrictions on H-1B visa holders and employment-based immigrants, including prohibiting their entry in 2020. Expected opposition from his immigration advisers and other factors make it unlikely that, if elected, Trump will pass into law or pursue as a serious legislative initiative granting green cards to all foreign graduates of U.S. universities.

      On June 19, 2024, Trump taped a podcast interview with venture capitalists on the show All-In. “What I want to do and what I will do is you graduate from a college, I think you should get automatically as part of your diploma a green card to be able to stay in this country,” said Trump. “And that includes junior colleges too, anybody graduates from a college. You go there for two years or four years.” Trump promised to address the issue on “day one.”

      Even bogus schools like Trump Uni will qualify…apparently.

      08/31/24 11:25 AM | Comment Link

    • Rich Bauer said...

      4

      Or Trump may be just trying to dump Melania’s US citizenship: Visa Fraud is DQed

      Melania traveled to the U.S. on a B-1 business visa and would not have been authorized to work in the U.S. while on a B-1 visa. In fact entering the U.S. on a B-1 visa and the individual intends to work for a U.S. employer, the individual will usually be denied admission. In order to avoid being sent back to Slovenia, she may have had to lie about the purpose of her trip. Visa fraud would call into question a green card application and subsequent citizenship application, thus raising questions about Melania Trump’s legal status, even today, despite her marriage to Donnie Dementia.

      09/1/24 12:33 PM | Comment Link

    • John Poole said...

      5

      Bauer: I tend to think as PVB does that a Trump presidency would be somewhat unorthodox but not the end of everything a blue blooded American considers the nation’s best qualities. But then again I’d consider Oscar Wilde as the head of an all boy’s school problematical today but also oddly beneficial since he was clearly an exceptional mind. One would need many hetero teachers to insure the principal had enough principles to keep the school from closing under clear scandals. open. Trump is perhaps a semi aware driven guy and with assistants with the gall to confront him we’ll be OK as a declining empire for another perhaps 20 years. Trump has just had a very late life mellowing. I’ll be completely dissolved in a mushroom canvas bag by that time.

      09/1/24 1:30 PM | Comment Link

    • John Poole said...

      6

      Bauer and others. Trump will do fine. He is a sane male. He is not crazy. Kamala on the other hand is a stupid person who sort of senses she is dense but still feels she deserves exalted promotions. We’re all safer with Trump at the helm rather than the stupid and clueless Harris. Some in DS better start packing and perhaps rightfully so. If you’re floating way above one’s grade then get ready to be “retired”. By the way what was your and PVB’s grade when you left DS or whatever your agency. Me?
      Sp4 after two years. I should have made Sp5 but too many NCO’s were resentful of my musicianship and the fact that a US was assigned 02N20 during the great Vietnam build up of ’67.Most were RA and had to join to be guaranteed a gig in an Army Band.

      09/2/24 4:33 PM | Comment Link

    • Rich Bauer said...

      7

      JP,

      We all know you aint stupid. You know Trump jumped the shark he lives in fear a very long time ago. But in case you need a more recent example:

      “She destroyed the city of San Francisco, it’s — and I own a big building there — it’s no — I shouldn’t talk about this but that’s OK I don’t give a damn because this is what I’m doing. I should say it’s the finest city in the world — sell and get the hell out of there, right? But I can’t do that. I don’t care, you know? I lost billions of dollars, billions of dollars. You know, somebody said, ‘What do you think you lost?’ I said, ‘Probably two, three billion. That’s OK, I don’t care.’ They say, ‘You think you’d do it again?’ And that’s the least of it. Nobody. They always say, I don’t know if you know. Lincoln was horribly treated. Uh, Jefferson was pretty horribly. Andrew Jackson they say was the worst of all, that he was treated worse than any other president. I said, ‘Do that study again, because I think there’s nobody close to Trump.’ I even got shot! And who the hell knows where that came from, right?”

      But then you still think Putin is thinking straight. So maybe…

      09/3/24 8:11 AM | Comment Link

    • John Poole said...

      8

      Bauer: Could we arrange a spot and time where the three of us could arrange a session of hearty laughter with our preferred alcoholic beverages in hand?

      09/3/24 4:26 PM | Comment Link

    • Rich Bauer said...

      9

      JP,

      If you have anything left in your Russian offshore bank accounts that are not in rubles, don’t invest in Donald J Trump social stock. The stock hit 18 today and could be worthless when the Orange Clown loses, which the 69% stock price decline anticipates. When Donnie Dementia loses all his money, he can identify with his supporters whom he considers losers. Maybe he can share a prison cell with Bannon, if he doesn’t get Epsteined. Would Putin give him political asylum?

      Melania will have to go back to her escort career, Barron will have to drop out of NYU, Eric and Don Jr will have to sell their kidneys, and Ivanka and Jared will immigrate to Albania. Peter will have to make an honest living.

      But Mr. Pool, what will become of you?

      09/3/24 4:35 PM | Comment Link

    • Rich Bauer said...

      10

      Now that the Trumpist Supremes gave Biden immunity for official acts, he can revoke passports issued to Trump voters. Pass an official act declaring Trump voters enablers of the domestic terrorist Trump an Enemy of State. There are already rules for revocation for IRS debt. By law (Internal Revenue Code Section 7345), the IRS will certify taxpayers with seriously delinquent tax debts to the State Department for specific actions regarding their passports. Generally, the State Department will not issue passports to taxpayers after receiving their delinquent debt certification from the IRS. They won’t care about losing their passports. Most Trumpists are xenophobes anyway.

      09/3/24 8:48 PM | Comment Link

    Leave A Comment

    Mail (will not be published) (required)